I also loved the Elimination Challenge: it was FABULOUS. It gave the chefs the chance to just cook something and cook it well. Plus, we at home got to play our own, “What would your last meal be?” game. Mine: Tex-Mex. Easy, no question. Chips and fresh salsa, guacamole, tamales, rice and beans, I’m happy. That, or pepperoni pizza. And Mac&Cheese. Damn! Other picks I heard: fillet Mignon, ribs, and biscuits & sausage gravy. mmmmmmm
The standout last night, and for the past couple of nights was, OBVIOUSLY, Carla.

I heard a bit of dissension from my Top Chef crew last night about Carla’s abilities, credentials and whether she really deserves to be in the top 4, but ultimately I think she does, and here’s why: she’s learned. Carla had all these problems stemming from her inability to focus and her tendency to do too much, but she learned, and she fixed them! She realized, “this isn’t working,” so she went another direction: good, simple, great tasting food, and guess what? It hits the mark every time!
I hate when the cheftestants, like Hosea, make all this fuss about “Do I go all out? Do I go traditional? Hows my facial hair?” etc. Look, its not what you do that matters, its HOW you do it, and if you don’t get that by now, then you are going to lose. Make. good. food. that’s it.
Another stand out last night: my lover Fabio who, with total class and stick-to-it-iveness, made a whole meal with only 9 fingers, and he didn’t even flaunt his handi-capability to the table of Chefs when he introduced his dish. Now THAT takes restraint, seriously!! Bravo, Fabio! You deserve 2 of those HUGE bottles of wine.
Total shit-shows: Leah, Hosea and Padma. Leah, Hosea: go away. I’m so glad Leah finally went home, it only would have been better if she’d taken Hosea with her. Hosea – you suck. You think Stefan is your only competition and I predict that that will be your undoing. And Padma, were you um… cold?

YOWZA!
And maybe…um…STONED? C’mon! I get why you would partake of the herb before eating a HUGE delicious meal, but on on TV, Padma! Kids watch this show!
Best Padma line of the night: “Your two kinds of Spinach tasted like one kind of Spinach.” THANKS!
Anyway, I’m satisfied with the final four, and I’m excited to see what happens in New Orleans. Preview: GAIL RETURNS, Fabio expresses his new found love for the Sex Pistols, and Carla meets a hair straightener. GOOD TIMES!
2 responses so far ↓
rockon211 // February 12, 2009 at 2:18 pm |
Did anyone else think Daddy Tom was going to pop out and say “Hey guys, we told you to make a simple meal – now do THIS” and they would have to do something crazy like bake a three layer cake using only the leftover ingredients and Diet Dr. Pepper (called the leftover DDP challenge)?! I kept saying this is not the whole challenge, but I ended up loving it regardless.
Allie you didn’t mention how TC totally veered from their “we don’t judge based on credibility, it’s only on this one challenge” motto. I think if this had been any other challenge other than the one-before-the-finale, Stefan would have gone home. Overcooking proteins is Daddy Tom’s pet peeve, but the German has dominated and it would wrong to send him home now. Plus Leah is whiney. See ya, Leah!
Love Carla. Love. She kills me. I don’t think she’ll win the whole thing (I will be shocked if it’s not Stefan, though I would love to see him knocked down a few more pegs) but I have my money on her winning fan favorite. I think she should roadtrip with Ripert AND Jacque!
jess // February 18, 2009 at 4:40 pm |
i enjoy the friday weekly roundup – can y’all bring that back if possible? thanks